celebrities

Who Is James Somerton? His YouTube Career and Scandal

James Somerton built a YouTube channel around a question many movie fans had asked themselves. Why did so many films seem to hint at queer characters and relationships while leaving them unspoken? His long-form essays gave viewers a way to talk about those details, from Disney villains to the portrayal of gay and trans people on screen. Over time, the channel grew to more than 300,000 subscribers.

Then, in December 2023, fellow video essayist Hbomberguy showed how closely parts of Somerton’s scripts matched published work by other writers. A separate video by Todd in the Shadows challenged historical claims in those essays. Within months, Somerton’s main channel had closed. The story is best understood through one Disney essay that had already raised questions about his use of sources three years earlier.

James Somerton Quick Facts

Quick factDetails
Full nameJames Somerton
Known forLong-form YouTube essays about LGBTQ+ representation in film and popular culture
Main subjectsQueer film history, Disney, horror and representation on screen
YouTube audienceMore than 300,000 subscribers before the scandal
Paid membershipApproximately 3,000 paying Patreon subscribers, according to film scholar Sean Griffin
Plagiarism investigationHbomberguy’s Plagiarism and You(Tube), released December 2, 2023
Separate fact-checkTodd in the Shadows’ video, released December 4, 2023
Public apologyDecember 20, 2023
Main channel closureReported in May 2024
Later business listingMemory Media, a wedding photography listing reported in April 2025

Early Life and Background

James Somerton’s public profile grew out of his videos. Details about his childhood, education and family background are limited. His exact age and height are also difficult to establish reliably, so the clearest account of his background begins with the work he published.

His interests as a creator were easy to see. He returned to questions about how filmmakers portrayed LGBTQ+ people, how audiences interpreted characters, and what older movies could tell us about the times in which they were made. Those themes gave the channel a recognizable identity even when the subjects changed from one upload to the next.

How James Somerton Built His YouTube Career

Somerton worked in the video essay format, using narration and film clips to develop an argument over the course of a video. A viewer could arrive because they liked a particular movie and leave thinking about how its characters were written, what the studio was willing to show, or why certain scenes had taken on a different meaning for queer audiences.

Disney gave him a subject many viewers already knew. An essay could begin with a familiar character and move into queer coding, a term for traits or cues that suggest a character may be queer even when the story leaves their identity unstated. Horror offered another angle, especially when discussing how movies use outsiders, fear and desire.

The channel’s growth was considerable for a creator working in a specialized corner of film criticism. Sean Griffin, a film scholar whose writing appeared in one of the videos, later put Somerton’s audience at more than 300,000 YouTube subscribers. Somerton also built a Patreon membership, which gave viewers a way to support his work with recurring payments.

The Disney Essay That Raised Questions in 2020

One of the clearest examples in the James Somerton scandal started well before the December 2023 investigation. In September 2020, a stranger contacted Sean Griffin about a video called Evil Queens: Disney’s Queer Cold War. Griffin had written Tinker Belles and Evil Queens, a book about the relationship between Disney and queer culture.

When Griffin watched the video, he recognized entire paragraphs from his book in the script. Somerton contacted him, apologized and sent him a revised version with an opening title card crediting Griffin and the book. Griffin said he was satisfied with the change at the time.

The exchange took on a different meaning in December 2023, when current and former students contacted Griffin about Hbomberguy’s investigation. What Griffin had handled as a problem with one video turned out to be part of a broader pattern. Other writers’ work had also appeared in Somerton’s narration, and the investigation gave viewers a way to see those parallels for themselves.

What Hbomberguy Found in James Somerton’s Videos

On December 2, 2023, Harry Brewis, better known as Hbomberguy, released Plagiarism and You(Tube). The video ran for nearly four hours and examined several creators. A substantial part focused on Somerton’s channel and the sources behind its scripts.

The comparisons were straightforward to follow. Viewers could hear Somerton’s narration and see a passage from an earlier book, article or video beside it. In some examples, the wording was nearly identical. In others, small changes left the original passage easy to recognize.

Journalist Gita Jackson, whose writing was among the work identified, later described learning how many other writers had been affected. For those writers, credit had a practical value. A clear reference could send an interested viewer to their article or book. When the words flowed straight into the narration, viewers had little reason to look for the person who originally wrote them.

What Todd in the Shadows Found

Two days after Hbomberguy’s video appeared, Todd in the Shadows released a separate fact-check. His focus was the accuracy of statements made in Somerton’s essays, including claims about queer history and popular culture. He challenged examples he found misleading, unsupported or contradicted by other sources.

The distinction mattered for anyone who had treated the videos as an introduction to a subject. Hbomberguy’s investigation helped viewers work out who had written the passages they heard. Todd’s fact-check gave them reasons to revisit some of the historical claims they might have remembered or repeated.

The Apology and YouTube Channel Closure

James Somerton made his videos private and took down his Patreon after the investigation drew widespread attention. On December 20, 2023, he posted an apology addressing the plagiarism. The response drew further criticism, and Plagiarism Today reported that his main YouTube account closed in May 2024.

Meanwhile, Brewis and his producer, Kat Lo, continued identifying people whose work had appeared in the videos. In January 2024, Brewis said they were compiling a list of affected creators so they could share advertising revenue from the investigation with them. Some of the writers had already spent years publishing in the field that Somerton’s channel introduced to many viewers.

What Happened After James Somerton Left YouTube?

In April 2025, Plagiarism Today reported that Somerton had advertised wedding photography services on WeddingWire under the business name Memory Media. The profile named him as the lead photographer. The publication reported that the listing used stock photographs as portfolio samples and that the profile was subsequently removed.

The listing was a separate business venture that surfaced after the closure of his main channel. Because the documented development concerned a wedding photography profile, it offers a limited view of what Somerton did after leaving YouTube.

Net Worth and Income

James Somerton earned money through YouTube advertising and paid Patreon memberships. Griffin cited around 3,000 paying Patreon subscribers before the scandal. That figure gives a sense of the size of the membership, but it cannot establish monthly earnings because subscription prices can vary and platforms charge fees.

A reliable estimate of Somerton’s net worth is unavailable. Subscriber totals measure audience size, while net worth depends on assets and debts. The public numbers tell us how many people watched or paid to support the channel, which is useful for understanding its reach.

Public Image and Legacy

Before the scandal, Somerton was known for bringing queer film criticism to viewers who might never have picked up a book on the subject. After the investigation, attention shifted to the writers and filmmakers whose work had helped shape those essays. Griffin’s experience illustrates that change. A book published more than two decades earlier suddenly became part of a wide public conversation about who gets credit for explaining film history.

The case also made a practical question about video essays easier to see. If a viewer wants to learn more about a striking claim or passage, can they tell where it came from? On a channel with hundreds of thousands of subscribers, the answer can affect whether the original writer gains readers or remains unknown to the people hearing their work.

Conclusion

James Somerton attracted a large audience by discussing queer themes in movies that many viewers already knew. His channel closed after Hbomberguy documented repeated use of other writers’ work and Todd in the Shadows challenged claims made in his essays.

The Disney video from 2020 remains a useful place to understand what happened. What first looked to one author like a credit problem he had resolved became, three years later, an example in a much larger account of how the channel’s scripts were put together.

FAQs About James Somerton

Who is James Somerton?
James Somerton is a former YouTube video essayist who covered LGBTQ+ representation in movies and popular culture. His channel had more than 300,000 subscribers before the plagiarism scandal.

What kind of videos did he make?
Somerton made long-form essays about queer film history, Disney, horror and how LGBTQ+ characters are portrayed. He used movie clips and narration to connect individual films with broader cultural topics.

Who exposed the James Somerton plagiarism scandal?
Harry Brewis, better known as Hbomberguy, brought the case to a wide audience in December 2023. His video compared Somerton’s scripts with earlier work from authors, journalists and other creators.

What did Todd in the Shadows investigate?
Todd checked the accuracy of claims in Somerton’s videos, including statements about queer history. His separate video appeared on December 4, 2023, two days after Hbomberguy’s investigation.

Did James Somerton apologize?
Yes. He published an apology video on December 20, 2023, after taking his essays out of public view. The apology drew further criticism.

When did James Somerton close his YouTube channel?
Plagiarism Today reported that he closed his main channel in May 2024. His videos had already been made private in December 2023.

What was Memory Media?
Memory Media was the name on a wedding photography listing associated with Somerton. In April 2025, Plagiarism Today reported that the profile used stock photos as portfolio samples and was later removed.

What is James Somerton’s net worth?
There is no reliable public estimate. YouTube advertising and Patreon memberships were sources of income, but public audience figures do not establish his earnings or personal wealth.

Related Articles

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Back to top button